Difference between revisions of "IPAC18LightPeerReview"

From CASA Wiki
Jump to: navigation, search
 
(55 intermediate revisions by 2 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
−
* 4/18  00:49: Akihiko Miura asked for reassignment of THYGBE4; Andrew Hutton asked;
+
'''Action Required by Todd/Alex'''
−
* 4/17  16:57: Rodrigo Junqueira asked for reassignment of THPML119; Riad Suleiman asked; accepted; assigned '''DONE'''
+
* 04/20 10:11: John Fox asked for consideration of WEPAL079
−
* 4/17  16:57: Rodrigo Junqueira asked for reassignment of THPML123; Kevin Jordan asked;
+
** Todd replied that we are looking but no promises
 +
* 04/20 09:41: Pardis Niknejadi asked for consideration of TUPML040
 +
** Todd replied that we are looking but no promises
 +
* 04/18  11:32: Peter Forck mistakenly reviewed THPML123 instead of WEPAF025; we need to delete his report for THPML123
 +
** 11:49 Todd emailed Matt with request, and Peter with info that he can add a new review to THPML123
 +
* 04/23 14:22: Todd emailed Vitaly Yakimenko, Mark Hogan re LWFA pulsed quad paper
 +
** 04/25 06:30: Mark replied, available early next week; Todd replied that we will mail them again if needed
 +
* 04/25 07:35: Susanna Guiducci inquired re THPAK023 yellow dot from Alex; how to proceed? (Todd thinks should be green)
 +
 
 +
'''AWAITING RESPONSES'''
 +
* 04/23 14:14: Todd emailed Kathy Harkay, Jim Clarke re three SC undulator papers
 +
** 04/23 23:15: Kathy replied, busy, recommended Ivanyushenkov and Casalbuoni
 +
*** 04/24 09:29: Ivanyushenkov replied, volunteered to take on SSRF paper; Todd assigned and mailed Yuri info
 +
*** 04/24 09:53: Sara replied, suggested Bahrdt, Bragin, Mezentsev
 +
** 04/25 06:34: Jim replied that he will take them on; Todd assigned and mailed Jim info
 +
 
 +
'''DONE''' items (basically in hands of reviewers)
 +
* 04/23 14:18: Todd emailed Zach Conway re CW ion linac paper
 +
** Brahim intervened and accepted
 
* 04/17 07:32: Weihao Liu asked for reassignment of THPAK106
 
* 04/17 07:32: Weihao Liu asked for reassignment of THPAK106
−
* 04/17 07:32: Weihao Liu asked for reassignment of THPAF037
+
** 04/19 10:22: Ciprian Plostinar asked; accepted, assigned
−
* 04/17 08:52: WEPAL010 needs peer reviewers assigned
+
* 04/17 16:57: Rodrigo Junqueira asked for reassignment of THPML119; Riad Suleiman asked; accepted; assigned
−
* 04/17 08:52: TUPML040 needs peer reviewers assigned
+
* 04/18  00:49: Akihiko Miura asked for reassignment of THYGBE4; Andrew Hutton asked; accepted; assigned
−
* 04/17 08:52: WEPAL079 needs peer reviewers assigned
+
* 04/17 12:08: Melissa Uchida asked for reassignment of WEPAL072; emailed; negotiating; agreed to take after all
−
* 04/17 08:52: TUPMF035 needs peer reviewers assigned
+
* 04/19  08:52: Wolfram Fisher asked to review F. Zimmermannn's paper MOPMF064; declined
−
* 04/17 08:52: THPAL092 needs peer reviewers assigned
+
* 04/19  08:35: Peter McIntyre asked to review F. Zimmermannn's paper MOPMF065; accepted;assigned
−
* 04/17 08:52: MOPMF064 needs peer reviewers assigned
+
* 04/17 16:57: Rodrigo Junqueira asked for reassignment of THPML123; Kevin Jordan asked;accepted
−
** Todd assigned as one reviewer (Zimmermann paper)
+
* 04/19  09:02: Sergei Nagaitsev asked to review F. Zimmermannn's paper MOPMF064; declined
−
* 04/17 08:52: MOPMF065 needs peer reviewers assigned
+
* 04/19 09:57: Mike Syphers/Alexey Burov asked to review MOPMF064; Alexey accepted
−
** Alex assigned as one reviewer (Zimmermann paper)
+
* 04/17 12:08: Melissa Uchida asked for reassignment of WEPAL058; removed, need to find peer reviewer
−
* 04/17 08:52: THPAK105 needs peer reviewers assigned
+
** 04/19 12:15: Jean-Luc Revol asked; declined
−
* 04/17 08:52: TUPMF037 needs peer reviewers assigned
+
** 04/19 12:29: Boris Podobedov asked; accepted; assigned
 +
* 04/17 09:00: Riad Suleiman asked for reassignment of TUPML015; removed; need to find peer reviewer
 +
** 04/19 11:52: Bruce Dunham asked; accepted; assigned
 
* 04/17 10:30: Walter Barkley asked for reassignment of WEPML046
 
* 04/17 10:30: Walter Barkley asked for reassignment of WEPML046
−
* 04/17 16:57: Roddrigo Leao asked for reassignment of THPML119
+
** 04/19 10:32: Sam Posen asked; declined
−
* 04/17 16:57: Roddrigo Leao asked for reassignment of THPML123
+
** 04/19 10:52: Frank Marhauser asked; accepted; assigned
 +
* 04/19 09:29: Lorenzo Teofili noted no comments on yellow dot THPAK091; emaild Peter Huelsmann (reviewer) to request comments
 +
** 04/20 09:30: Peter provided comments, Todd forwarded to Lorenzo
 +
* 04/17 09:00: Riad Suleiman asked for reassignment of THPML006; removed; need to find peer reviewer
 +
** 04/19 11:59: Geoff Krafft asked; declined
 +
** 04/20 08:29: Chris Tennant asked
 +
** 04/20 10:46: Todd assigned back to Riad, who accepted it back
 +
* 04/20 10:45: Todd realized that newly-assigned reviewers are not getting notification email
 +
** Sent email to Frank Marhauser (WEPML046)
 +
** Sent email to Alexey Burov (MOPMF064)
 +
** Sent email to Bruce Dunham (TUPML015)
 +
'''Action Required by Others'''

Latest revision as of 08:10, 25 April 2018

Action Required by Todd/Alex

  • 04/20 10:11: John Fox asked for consideration of WEPAL079
    • Todd replied that we are looking but no promises
  • 04/20 09:41: Pardis Niknejadi asked for consideration of TUPML040
    • Todd replied that we are looking but no promises
  • 04/18 11:32: Peter Forck mistakenly reviewed THPML123 instead of WEPAF025; we need to delete his report for THPML123
    • 11:49 Todd emailed Matt with request, and Peter with info that he can add a new review to THPML123
  • 04/23 14:22: Todd emailed Vitaly Yakimenko, Mark Hogan re LWFA pulsed quad paper
    • 04/25 06:30: Mark replied, available early next week; Todd replied that we will mail them again if needed
  • 04/25 07:35: Susanna Guiducci inquired re THPAK023 yellow dot from Alex; how to proceed? (Todd thinks should be green)

AWAITING RESPONSES

  • 04/23 14:14: Todd emailed Kathy Harkay, Jim Clarke re three SC undulator papers
    • 04/23 23:15: Kathy replied, busy, recommended Ivanyushenkov and Casalbuoni
      • 04/24 09:29: Ivanyushenkov replied, volunteered to take on SSRF paper; Todd assigned and mailed Yuri info
      • 04/24 09:53: Sara replied, suggested Bahrdt, Bragin, Mezentsev
    • 04/25 06:34: Jim replied that he will take them on; Todd assigned and mailed Jim info

DONE items (basically in hands of reviewers)

  • 04/23 14:18: Todd emailed Zach Conway re CW ion linac paper
    • Brahim intervened and accepted
  • 04/17 07:32: Weihao Liu asked for reassignment of THPAK106
    • 04/19 10:22: Ciprian Plostinar asked; accepted, assigned
  • 04/17 16:57: Rodrigo Junqueira asked for reassignment of THPML119; Riad Suleiman asked; accepted; assigned
  • 04/18 00:49: Akihiko Miura asked for reassignment of THYGBE4; Andrew Hutton asked; accepted; assigned
  • 04/17 12:08: Melissa Uchida asked for reassignment of WEPAL072; emailed; negotiating; agreed to take after all
  • 04/19 08:52: Wolfram Fisher asked to review F. Zimmermannn's paper MOPMF064; declined
  • 04/19 08:35: Peter McIntyre asked to review F. Zimmermannn's paper MOPMF065; accepted;assigned
  • 04/17 16:57: Rodrigo Junqueira asked for reassignment of THPML123; Kevin Jordan asked;accepted
  • 04/19 09:02: Sergei Nagaitsev asked to review F. Zimmermannn's paper MOPMF064; declined
  • 04/19 09:57: Mike Syphers/Alexey Burov asked to review MOPMF064; Alexey accepted
  • 04/17 12:08: Melissa Uchida asked for reassignment of WEPAL058; removed, need to find peer reviewer
    • 04/19 12:15: Jean-Luc Revol asked; declined
    • 04/19 12:29: Boris Podobedov asked; accepted; assigned
  • 04/17 09:00: Riad Suleiman asked for reassignment of TUPML015; removed; need to find peer reviewer
    • 04/19 11:52: Bruce Dunham asked; accepted; assigned
  • 04/17 10:30: Walter Barkley asked for reassignment of WEPML046
    • 04/19 10:32: Sam Posen asked; declined
    • 04/19 10:52: Frank Marhauser asked; accepted; assigned
  • 04/19 09:29: Lorenzo Teofili noted no comments on yellow dot THPAK091; emaild Peter Huelsmann (reviewer) to request comments
    • 04/20 09:30: Peter provided comments, Todd forwarded to Lorenzo
  • 04/17 09:00: Riad Suleiman asked for reassignment of THPML006; removed; need to find peer reviewer
    • 04/19 11:59: Geoff Krafft asked; declined
    • 04/20 08:29: Chris Tennant asked
    • 04/20 10:46: Todd assigned back to Riad, who accepted it back
  • 04/20 10:45: Todd realized that newly-assigned reviewers are not getting notification email
    • Sent email to Frank Marhauser (WEPML046)
    • Sent email to Alexey Burov (MOPMF064)
    • Sent email to Bruce Dunham (TUPML015)

Action Required by Others

Retrieved from "https://casa.jlab.org/wiki/index.php?title=IPAC18LightPeerReview&oldid=2412"